Resisting Fascist Gender Ideologies and Theorizing Marxist-Humanist Alternatives

Heather A. Brown

Summary: As women’s and LGBTQ+ rights in the US drift further toward fascism how can we resist this turn? — Editors

Trump and his MAGA supporters are working from the fascist playbook, which seeks to strip subjectivity from the masses. Because gender is so tied to modern conceptions of self and because family (however defined) is necessary for the socialization of the next generation of citizens, control over gender by the state is a necessity for fascists. Assertions of biological necessity for certain traits in men and women undermine possibilities for individual and collective subjectivity when behavior can be labelled “unnatural.” The state must then protect the subjected citizen from all threats to orthodoxy, both external and internal, and any measures are warranted as the “unnatural” must be stopped at all costs. As we see here on gender as well as many other issues, the state has been willing to commit atrocities in the name of a good, natural order. It is only through collective action of all progressive voices that we can hope to drive back this monstrosity.

In the US and elsewhere, we are seeing increased attacks on individual freedom in the name of protecting the community (of heterosexual white cisgendered people). One area where this is readily apparent is on the issue of gender. Evincing sexual panics is nothing new to fascist politics. In the US, this is happening on a number of fronts, including transgender rights, abortion rights and other issues of sexual self-determination.

Since the election of Trump in 2024, the US has seen the erosion of rights for women and the LGBTQ+ community. Starting with his executive order in January 2025, the Trump administration has sought to elevate those that MAGA sees as embodying their normative vision of womanhood (and manhood), while at the same time working to marginalize and silence anyone who doesn’t fit into these categories. While the executive order may have put forward a minimalist definition for “biological” sex (production of ova or sperm),[1] statements and policy from this administration have filled in the gaps.

MAGA’s War on Trans, Non-Binary and Intersexed People

It is no surprise that one of Trump’s first executive orders as he returned to office was to define “biological sex.” This executive order, while absurd on the face of it, has become the basis for federal policy toward transgender individuals and serves as a basis for the possible oppression of any group or individual which runs astray of the administration’s notion of gender roles. The order itself is relatively simple. It says that federal policy now defines “biological sex” as “an individual’s immutable biological classification as either male or female.” Females are those that “at conception” belong to “the sex that produces the large reproductive cell” and males are those that “at conception” belong to “the sex that produces the small reproductive cell.”[2]

There are several problems with these definitions. While at first, it seems as though the issue of pointing to sex as it exists at conception is nonsensical. After all, a human female doesn’t actually produce ova until later in the gestational period and males don’t produce sperm until after puberty. This phrasing is there for a few reasons, however. First, sex must be immutable according to MAGA, thus, there can be no process involved. It has to happen at conception, otherwise there is a process that happens to create the human female and male. Process means that “accidents” can happen and something other than a clear male or female is produced (i.e. an intersexed, transgender, or other non-binary individual). Second, while unspoken in the actual text, there is the assumption that producing ova or sperm leads to other gender-based behaviors such as being nurturing and motherly or protective and fatherly. There is no reason to assume that because one produces a certain type of reproductive cell, they will display specific behaviors.

Scientifically, it would seem more likely that either the Y chromosome or sex-based hormones would play a larger role in predicting sex-based behaviors. Both fail on account of the need for sex to be immutable from conception and that there be only two sexes. For example, there are individuals that don’t have the XX or XY chromosomes solely and even those with XX or XY chromosomes do not always develop according to plan (i.e. intersexed people). Sex hormones themselves cannot be the answer either because even if we acknowledge that testosterone and estrogen produce clear gendered behaviors (and there is no unambiguous evidence that it does), males and females produce both testosterone and estrogen, albeit in varying quantities. In these ways, sex really does seem like a spectrum rather than two distinct entities.

However, Trump insists that it is the Left that inserts “gender ideology” into politics and social life:

“Gender ideology” replaces the biological category of sex with an ever-shifting concept of self-assessed gender identity, permitting the false claim that males can identify as and thus become women and vice versa, and requiring all institutions of society to regard this false claim as true.  Gender ideology includes the idea that there is a vast spectrum of genders that are disconnected from one’s sex.  Gender ideology is internally inconsistent, in that it diminishes sex as an identifiable or useful category but nevertheless maintains that it is possible for a person to be born in the wrong sexed body.[3]

The above science lesson illustrates the opposite; that actual biological sex is complicated and based on a process rather than being immutable. Moreover, it is intertwined in ways that we don’t fully understand with social conventions. While we can speak of distinct categories of sex and gender for analytic clarity, it may not be possible to always to separate the two in reality.

The problem with Trump’s assessment is not just that it is unscientific and ultimately wrong, but that a seemingly dry and banal discussion of sex can lead to real world oppression. The main purpose of the executive order is to naturalize two distinct sexes and to label anything else as “gender ideology,” placing any dissent on the issue in the realm of unnatural. Thus, trans individuals in the military are dishonest and untrustworthy because they insist that they know themselves better than the military does and that their assigned sex at birth and their perceived gender don’t match.

Marginalized groups provide a negative example to the ideal type described by Trump. Trans women are predators and brutes always ready to leer at and attack “true” women in bathrooms and locker rooms or will cause harm in sports because of their testosterone fueled musculature. “True” women are the innocent victims that need the protection of “real” men and the state. Victim, perpetrator and hero all become one-dimensional caricatures lacking any real subjectivity in this narrative. One is just to play their part without any improvising. Both in the past and the present, those who refuse to play their part will be erased.

The executive order referenced above erases intersexed, Trans and other non-binary individuals in its assertion of two sexes that are clear and present at conception. With this erasure from the public record comes hate and violence. For example, GLAAD’s Alert Desk reported 932 anti-LGBTQ incidents from May 1, 2024-May 1, 2025, with 52% of those targeting trans and non-gender conforming individuals. This is up 14% from the previous year.[4] Violent attacks included 84 injuries and 10 deaths.[5]

Similarly, the moral panic over trans people using the restrooms or locker rooms of their lived gender comes from fascistic notions of the natural and unnatural. Ask someone who believes that transgender individuals shouldn’t be allowed to use the bathrooms of their choice to name one specific instance where a cisgendered woman or girl has been attacked by a trans woman and they likely will not be able to provide an answer. However, ask any women (cisgendered or otherwise) why they watch their drink at a bar or a party or why they frequently look behind themselves as they walk alone late at night and they are likely to say that they are worried about (cisgendered) male predators attacking them. They will likely be able to give at least one specific example from a friend or even from their own experiences as sexual assault committed by cisgendered men is an all-too-common experience for those that identify as women. Yet there are 61 state bills introduced in 2026 that would ban trans individuals from using their lived gender bathroom just in schools[6] and none banning men from public spaces.

Moreover, it will not only be trans women that face scrutiny on what bathroom or locker room they use or sports team they join. Any woman who looks remotely masculine or performs too well in their sport, will likely have their femininity scrutinized. So much for the vaunted right of privacy that MAGA extolls for cisgendered women but not for those who cannot or will not perform the “correct” gender codes.

Trans people who participated in the Stonewall rebellion have been erased from the historical memory by the Trump administration. While it is well-documented that some of the most militant participants in that event that signaled the beginning of the modern LGBTQ+ movement in the US, in February of 2025, the Trump administration removed references to transgender people on the Stonewall National Monument website. Further, the National Park Service has replaced LGBTQ+ on their website with LGB in full correspondence to Trump’s executive order.[7] If sex is immutable, then trans, queer, non-binary, asexual people, etc. are aberrations that don’t need to be referenced by the government aside from their need to be policed. For reasons that will be discussed more fully below, one has to wonder when fascistic gender and sexual purity will seek to erase LGB as well.

Perhaps most disturbing is the attack on trans children. In the name of protecting trans children from grooming as well as causing harm to themselves through gender affirming care, Trump has banned gender affirming care for anyone under the age of 19. This is largely enforced by the threat of defunding any hospital or medical provider that offers this care in terms of research funds and any public health funds such as Medicare and Medicaid.[8] In most instances, hospitals, clinics and other medical providers have complied.

However, despite Trump’s solicitousness for trans children, these policies are likely to worsen their situation. For example, a study in the peer reviewed journal Nature Human Behavior found that where anti-transgender laws were passed from 2018-2022, the rates of attempted suicide for trans and non-binary youth increased by 72%.[9] This referenced all types of laws that targeted trans individuals. One can safely assume that a policy at the federal level that targets their right to bodily autonomy will at the very least do nothing to improve the mental health of these young people.

Moreover, the argument that this is being done to protect children from later regret for their actions does not bear scrutiny. Certainly, some do regret the transition decision, but for most that do, it is not because they realize that they are not trans, but because they regret the timing or that they lack the support that they need.[10] Further, surgical procedures are only very rarely performed on minors (less than 0.04%).[11] If only Trump and his ilk cared that much about the real cases of surgical mutilation of infant intersexed individuals that occur even today. Here young children’s bodies are made to conform to the average male or female and have faced pain, sterilization and sexual disfunction as a result of decisions that were made before they could even speak let alone consent.[12] It seems as though the right to bodily autonomy only goes to those that can and will adhere to what is considered “natural” for a person’s sex.

Women and Bodily Autonomy

The disastrous Dobbs ruling by the Supreme Court in 2022 set the stage for draconian laws involving abortion. Currently, 13 states have a total abortion ban, 4 states have bans at 6 weeks, 3 states have bans between 7-18 weeks and 21 states have bans after 18 weeks.[13] In practice, this means that women in 17 states have no real right to abortion as at 6 weeks, many women will not know that they are pregnant. Moreover, in 2025 alone 13 states introduced bills that would bring homicide charges against a person for having an abortion.[14]

Protection of women now, as in the past, has only applied to white women (and only to varying degrees depending on their class status and their willingness to adhere to the gender codes of the time). While the 2022 Dobbs ruling theoretically takes reproductive control out of the control of all women, in reality, some women have the power and status to take control of their bodies while many have far fewer options. Mothers in states that have banned abortion are nearly two times more likely to die than those that have access to legal abortion. Black women, who have already faced greater mortality from childbirth are hit particularly hard. While one in eight women in the US are Black, one in four lived in states with abortion bans in 2023. Moreover, “The maternal mortality rate in banned states for Black women, 60.9 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births, was significantly higher than the rate for White (18.2) or Latina (18.2) women.”[15]

Undocumented immigrants face similar issues. Particularly appalling is the ICE policy of sending young pregnant women and girls as young as 13 to Texas where abortion is banned, a majority of which have become pregnant as a result of sexual assault, forcing them to give birth to their rapist’s child before shipping them off to whatever country will take them.[16]

A similar logic to that discussed above regarding anti-trans policies can be used to point to MAGA’s views on abortion. Leaving aside for the moment the protection of life argument, abortion is unnatural to the sort of view evinced in Trump’s Executive Order on “biological” sex. If production of ova defines the female, then reproduction must be their major purpose. After all, why would there be the need to carve out sex differences so strongly if they weren’t essential to the core purposes of human beings? It follows that abortion for any purpose including rape is unnatural from this perspective. We protect not only the fetus, but also the woman and society by forced pregnancy. The fetus gets a chance at life (however meager that might be due to the social status of the mother), the woman gets to fulfill her life’s primary purpose and society is potentially freed from these “unnatural” women who will infect those around her with her pernicious ideology of freedom and bodily autonomy.

Even as women fight for the right not to be pregnant the FDA is working to undermine this right. Medication abortions have increased from 53% in 2020 to 63% in 2023, just one year after Dobbs, in part because of the expanded use of telehealth for prescribing these medications even in those states with total bans.[17] Now the battle is playing out over the use of Mifepristone, one of the two drugs most commonly prescribed for medication abortions. In 2025, Louisiana initiated a lawsuit challenging an FDA decision to allow the drug to be delivered by mail although at this point, there is no stay on the delivery by mail as the case plays out. While the drug has been available and used for abortions since 2000, the FDA is now conducting a review of the safety of the drug, despite the safe and widespread use since this time.[18] If MAGA has anything to say about it, women will be relegated to the role of mothers serving the state.

 

“Enemy Feminisms”

In Enemy Feminisms: TERFs, Policewomen, & Girlbosses Against Liberation, Sophie Lewis makes a case that truly fascist feminisms can and do exist. While I can’t offer a full review here, Lewis makes a compelling case for naming and shaming feminists who are not really interested in liberatory politics and in fact, work against it (albeit with some problematic elements such as a silence over Non-Western forces that have been just as destructive of progressive feminisms).[19] Particularly relevant for the current discussion are TERFs, who have made significant inroads in Britain and the US. One of the main reasons why TERFs have such a problem with trans people is because they, as J.K. Rowling writes “erode ‘women’ as a political and biological class.”[20]

Lewis repeatedly makes reference to the fact that many of these regressive feminists including TERFs came out of the cultural feminist movement which sought to exalt women as women. While there is nothing wrong with valuing the cultures of oppressed groups, especially as they seek to remove the ideological chains of the oppressor, staying at that point in the long-term can be problematic and in some instances counter-revolutionary. As Fanon repeatedly points out in The Wretched of the Earth, true transformation can only come when one uses the particular to find a way toward the universal. He writes in terms of the narrowness of nationalism which is not broadened by a humanism which acknowledges the concrete of the particular while at the same time recognizing the universality of needs: “But if nationalism is not made explicit, if it is not enriched and deepened by a very rapid transformation into a consciousness of social and political needs, in other words into humanism, it leads up a blind alley.”[21] In the present case, how can those labelled as women move beyond a celebration of themselves, which often includes scars and coping mechanisms wrought from the wounds inflected by society based on their position in it, to one that reaches toward human emancipation?

While there may be elements of the TERFs as well as some of their supporters who are genuinely concerned about protecting women’s spaces from those that would monopolize those spaces, their position is nonetheless problematic. There is a long record of favored elements of oppressed groups speaking over those who have less privilege, for example, white women drowning out the voices of minority women within the feminist movement. That, however, doesn’t necessitate that the reverse is also true. Cisgendered women are very much the privileged group to trans women. Experience growing up as male in a male dominated society may initially lead to the practice of trans women interrupting and ignoring cisgendered women, however, anatomy is not destiny. There is nothing inherent in someone’s plumbing that makes them interested in domination. For most, honest conversation and practices like time limits on speaking and calling on those that haven’t spoken should mitigate the majority of the problem. For those that refuse to follow common sense community guidelines expulsion is a viable option.

The difference between individual and collective expulsion is that collective measures almost always assume bad faith on the side of those facing punishment. Trans women will not just want to dominate discussion in women’s only spaces but also, they are deviants and predators. After all, who would want to give up their privilege and join the underclass unless they were either crazy or could gain some perverse pleasure from mocking standard gender codes? Here the positions of TERFs and Trumpists line up in some odd ways. For both anatomy is destiny, women need their own spaces and need to be protected from non-cisgendered women.

Thinking About Gender in the New Society Dialectically

Given the information above, along with many other aspects of women and LGBTQ+ lives that have been made more difficult over the past few years, it is easy to fall into despair. However, there have been a number of positive elements that we should reflect on. First, when it comes to the right to abortion, the situation is not as bleak as it first appears. This is largely due to the inability of states to regulate the prescribing of abortion pills by mail. Women who otherwise couldn’t gain access to abortions can meet virtually with healthcare providers from out of state, who will then prescribe medications for inducing an abortion. Given the history of protection of interstate commerce in the US constitution and in practice, it is unlikely that a law to ban the practice could pass constitutional muster, let alone get passed the drafting stage. Companies like CVS and Express Scripts would quickly object to the proposed policy which could compromise their bottom line and disrupt patient privacy. After all, Mifepristone is far from the only drug that is sent by mail.

There have also been shield laws created by seven states to make it more difficult for states to prosecute providers that give out these prescriptions. Moreover, an additional ten states and Washington DC have laws that protect providers from prosecution from outside the state for care occurring within the state.[22] This just goes to show that in an interconnected world, people will find a way to get around draconian laws. In fact, the number of abortions performed pre-Dobbs v. post-Dobbs have increased.[23]

Similarly, in LGBTQ+ rights, there have been some modest wins as well. If the majority decision on Dobbs was seen as horrible, Thomas’ concurring opinion arguing that since the right to privacy in the constitution referenced in Roe v. Wade and other reproductive rights and LGBTQ+ rights cases was overturned, cases dealing with same sex marriage and interracial marriage should also be looked at by the Court. Despite or perhaps because of the vast number of cases that the Court has controversially ruled on, this idea remains on the back burner for at least the moment. Moreover, despite efforts to permanently remove the Pride Flag from Stonewall, it is flying high today as a result of protests and legal action. Trump may have the support of MAGA Republicans for draconian gender codes and silencing of dissent from those who are different, but that support will only go so far.

On Trans rights, there have also been some modest wins. In 2025, eight states enacted or expanded shield laws, which try to protect families and providers from “out-of-state interference in gender affirming care,” bringing the total number of states that provide these sorts of protections to seventeen and these states contain about 39% of transgender youth in the US.[24] In the courtroom, there have been at least temporary wins regarding trans youth’s right to gender affirming care and on the trans military ban to name a few. Moreover, candidates such as Zohran Mamdani ran a pro-trans campaign and won[25] and trans, nonbinary and nongender conforming representation in public office has increased by a staggering 1,800% since 2017.[26] With majorities in certain parts of the country willing to accept trans, non-binary and gender non-conforming individuals as their representatives (at least when they stay inside the bounds of mainstream politics), it is no wonder why the Trumpists are trying to crack down as hard as they are. Despite the severe backlash against non-cisgendered people, many trans, non-binary and nongender conforming individuals are not simply going to go into hiding. The question remains: what can Marxist-Humanists offer to women and the LGBTQ+ community?

In the 1844 Manuscripts, Marx takes up in an extremely brief and abstract way, the progression of gender relations and how it illustrates progress toward the fully developed human being:

The immediate, natural and necessary relation of human being to human being is also the relation of man [Mann] to woman [Weib]. In this natural species relationship man’s [Mensch] relation to nature is directly his relation to man [Mensch], and his relation to man [Mensch] is directly his relation to nature, to his own natural function. Thus, in this relation is sensuously revealed, reduced to an observable fact, the extent to which human nature has become nature for him. From this relationship man’s [Mensch] whole level of development can be assessed. It follows from the character of this relationship how far man [Mensch] has become, and has understood himself as, a species-being, a human being. The relation of man [Mann] to woman [Weib] is the most natural relation of human being to human being. It indicates, therefore, how far man’s [Mensch] natural behavior has become human, and how far his human essence has become a natural essence for him, how far his human nature has become nature for him. It also shows how far man’s [Mensch] needs have become human needs, and consequently how far the other person [Mensch], as a person, has become one of his needs, and to what extent he is in his individual existence at the same time a social being.[27]

Of particular note here is how Marx moves from the abstract universal— the unmediated, “natural” human understanding of species being where survival and thus reproduction is the primary link between individuals to the concrete universal where every human being regardless of gender (and today we could add sexuality) are both beings for themselves and for others—i.e., the individual is valued both in terms of who they are and what they can become as well as being a representative of the species being for others. As reproduction loses some of its importance in human relations—it becomes one of a much larger set of essential human relationships—the need for conforming to societal expectations of gender consequently also loses much of its importance. The full and free release of individuality where nothing interferes with the universal becomes possible at this point.

The question remains: how do we purposefully move from the abstract to the concrete? For all its failures and missteps, liberalism at its best was able to bring in whole groups to political society on a relatively equal basis (at least where capitalist relations didn’t get in the way). However, treating every group and individual as equal, when they are most certainly not is a recipe for oppression of those that can’t meet that abstract notion of equality due to social or other circumstances. A path forward must acknowledge the limitations of the liberal state as well as its importance for a group like our own to operate.

As Marx argues in “The Jewish Question”, the liberal democratic state at its best does not recognize the concrete individual, but only one abstracted from everything else. This citizen theoretically has equal rights in the political sphere, but in practice this is far from true since political equality is achieved only by abstracting out all difference. This difference remains outside of the political sphere and limits participation in civil society and politics. Any effort of the state to remedy this inequality will lead to some arguing that the state is giving special treatment to these groups as MAGA has repeatedly done. Marx’s discussion of the liberal state of his and its relationship to the Jewish minority points us to the possibility of developing a similar theory of why states will necessarily vacillate on LGBTQ+ and women’s rights because the nature of the state relative to the individual is contradictory.

While we cannot rely on the state to be a consistent supporter of LGBTQ+ rights, an understanding of how the state functions is essential for its instrumental use in times where attenuation of oppression is needed in the short term and for theorizing a way out of this racist, sexist, classist, heteropatriarchal system. Marx specifically points out in “The Jewish Question” that although the liberal state is certainly a major advance over the repressive monarchies of the time, its limitations could be seen as it related to the possibility for equal rights for Jewish people. The general argument can certainly apply to any group that finds itself as a minority. As much as organization for change may have temporary results for groups that face either state or private oppression, it is clear that even state regulation of civil rights is not nearly enough to secure full emancipation for women and non-traditional gender conforming individuals, as is indicated by the current multinational debate over transgender and women’s rights because these rights cannot go far enough. While liberal rights in and of themselves are not enough for the creation of a post-capitalist society, without basic democratic rights and protections, theorizing and organizing to build such a society becomes much more difficult for a group like ours.

Moreover, as Marx points out, simple political equality is not human emancipation.  In fact, the abolition of a distinction must presuppose that the distinction actually exists. This distinction is then alienated from the individual’s species being: the state ignores the difference of the individual in order to bring them into the community. Thus, the individual is fractured into multiple parts where only the most abstract aspects of humanity are acknowledged by the state and by other human beings. One remains a citizen, but qualifiers must always be added which can ultimately lead to a sort of second-class citizenship. For example, women are politically equal to men in the US but face discrimination on the job market, in the political sphere and in terms of the right to control their own bodies in part because they contain an identity that is not part of the abstract citizen that is recognized by the state. They have the capacity to produce new human life—something that is difficult, labor intensive and can take away from the standard of what abstract civic duty, or the employer-employee contract represents. In the liberal state, difference is acknowledged and alienated from the individual’s species being, leading to a separated public and private individual that must constantly fight to retain the full rights seemingly granted with citizenship. In a fascist system that the US seems to be moving towards, these rights that were sporadically granted to various minority groups are turned into reasons to remove them from the political sphere and make them subject to the whims of those in power. Difference is made to serve as a means to divide in service of creating a unity against those that are othered. Rather than a political negotiation of differences and rights, those who are different are rendered “unnatural” and the enemy of society.

While writing on how the Communist movement should proceed in light of the post-1848 political order, in the “Address to the Communist League” (1850), Marx points to the importance of attenuating oppression perpetuated by the state and society in the short term while at the same time, working toward building new theory and practice to develop the new society in the longer term. He writes, “The relation of the revolutionary workers’ party to the petty-bourgeois democrats is this: it marches together with them against the faction which it aims at overthrowing, it opposes them in everything whereby they seek to consolidate their position in their own interests.”[28] Acknowledging that even the more seemingly progressive bourgeois voices would at best need to be pushed into protecting workers’ rights and at worst would need to be opposed, Marx makes a strong case for what he refers to as “Revolution in Permanence,”[29] or the need to constantly work out in theory what the new society would look like and hold fast to that in terms of pushing the envelope as far as possible in the short-term to mitigate the worst elements of capitalist repression. These short-term efforts to push for change that is possible in the system develop the skills of the working class, making it possible to work toward the long-term goal of building a society worthy of humanity’s potential. As the working class develops their political and social skills, the “Revolution in Permanence” begins with revolutionaries concretizing and building social relations that can eventually lead to the new society. Throughout the process, it is the dialectical interchange between theory and practice that drives progressive change. Constant interrogation of the world as it is and what we want it to be are necessary in order to not fall into counterrevolution. Today, this is a strategy that we need to follow on a number of points including on women’s and LGBTQ+ rights.

We can’t stop at either the liberal much less the fascist side of things. We need to theorize and practice a radical humanistic dialectics that incorporates the full complexity and potential of the human being down to the individual representative of that humanity. Moving beyond the notion that we all have to be abstractly equal to one where people are valued for both belonging to the species as such and for their unique contributions is largely new territory.

Marx makes an admittedly abstract attempt at explaining this. He writes that as society transitions to regard individuals less and less on the basis of a quid pro quo relationship, it would move toward appreciating individuals in all their concreteness:

In a higher phase of communist society, after the enslaving subordination of the individual to the division of labor, and thereby also the antithesis between mental and physical labor, has vanished; after labor has become not only a means of life but life’s prime desire and necessity [erste Lebensbedürfniss]; after the productive forces have also increased with the all-round development of the individual, and all the springs of cooperative wealth flow more abundantly, only then can the narrow horizon of bourgeois right be completely transcended [überschritten] and society inscribe on its banners: From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs![30]

“From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs” is no small feat as I have learned in a small way in the classroom. I teach at a virtually non-selective university where I have some students who can barely string sentences together to write a paper, others who are working multiple jobs for over 40 hours a week, and still others who care for younger siblings or sick family members. How can they be expected to compete with the “average” college student that has the education, time and family that is able to financially and otherwise support their education as the most important thing they are currently doing? The answer is they can’t and often through no fault of their own. Treating my students equally fundamentally means acknowledging the structural barriers that many of them face and working with them to get them to as equal of a position as possible. That is one of the positives of the much maligned “diversity, equity and inclusion.”

How can our organization work toward uplifting the voices of those who can bear children and trans individuals? Here, I don’t have a lot of clear or worked out answers, but as the above discussion points to, the need for bodily integrity and personal subjectivity is a must. Cisgendered women and anyone capable of bearing children (including some trans men) should have the right to choose to have or not have children. The state should have no role in this other than providing rational health and safety regulations that put the patient first, while at the same time providing services that help individuals to financially and otherwise support a child. Second, trans individuals (as should all people) should have the right to self-definition. This means rights to seemingly small things like being called by their chosen pronouns to undergoing (or not) social and medical gender affirming care to being able to change legal documents without medical intervention if that is their choice.

We can assist in this process by listening to and working with individuals and groups that are advocating for the sort of humanist and liberatory society that we would like to see whether that is through coalitions with other organizations or through our members working on their own with others. One factor that has been problematic to our organization has been the lack of women members in our organization. For some obvious reasons, women have historically not wanted to join with Marxists as many Marxists have evinced the idea that women’s liberation will come with the end of capitalism. Our organization, however, has never been a proponent of this position and, in fact, Raya spilled significant ink on this topic whether it was in critiquing Engels for The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, or when she was pointing to how women were very much a part of the revolutionary movement because of their position as women (i.e., the Paris Commune, the Abolitionist Movement, the miners’ wives in the 1950s, etc.) We need to renew a discussion both within our organization and with friends of the organization on the question of how we can recruit and retain more women members.

While issues of women’s bodily autonomy are much more visible in the US political sphere today, trans rights discussions are in a more precarious position. Because of violence, social ostracism and state repression, it is much harder for the trans community to have a positive presence. Here is a space where we can be useful to listen to their voices and help them project a positive vision of their future. A starting point for the organization might be to take a look at our 2023 Trans Statement and consider revising it. Much has changed since this time and with the help of comrades on our periphery, we may be able to add something important to the debate. I, for one, would be happy to volunteer for such a project.

All the while as we are working to build a new society free of hierarchical relations, we must continue to keep in mind that phrase from Marx: “From each according to his ability to each according to his need.” We are a long way off from that point today, but we must keep in mind the need for concretizing the relations between the individual in society in such a way that does not put new chains on human beings lest that phrase become a hollow pipe dream.

 

********

Adapted from a presentation to the July 2026 Convention of the International Marxist-Humanist Organization.

[1] ACLU, “Trump’s Executive Orders Promoting Sex Discrimination, Explained,” https://wp.api.aclu.org/news/lgbtq-rights/trumps-executive-orders-promoting-sex-discrimination-explained

 

[2] Trump, Donald. “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government” January 20, 2025. https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/defending-women-from-gender-ideology-extremism-and-restoring-biological-truth-to-the-federal-government/

 

[3] Ibid.

[4] GLAAD, “2025 GLAAD ALERT Desk Report: GLAAD’s Anti-LGBTQ Extremism Reporting Tracker.” https://glaad.org/2025-alert-desk/

 

[5] GLAAD, “GLAAD ALERT Desk Data Shows Dramatic Rise in Anti-Trans Hate Incidents,” June 2, 2025. https://glaad.org/glaad-alert-desk-data-shows-dramatic-rise-in-anti-trans-hate-incidents/

[6] https://www.aclu.org/legislative-attacks-on-lgbtq-rights-2026?impact=school__facilities

 

[7] Brajesh Upadhyay, “Transgender references removed from Stonewall monument website,” February 14, 2025. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cglywwn29n6o

 

[8] Trump, Donald. “Protecting Children from Chemical and Surgical Mutilation” January 28, 2025. https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/protecting-children-from-chemical-and-surgical-mutilation/

 

[9] “Anti-Transgender Laws Cause up to 72% Increase in Suicide Attempts Among Transgender and Nonbinary Youth, Study Shows.” September 26, 2024. https://www.thetrevorproject.org/blog/anti-transgender-laws-cause-up-to-72-increase-in-suicide-attempts-among-transgender-and-nonbinary-youth-study-shows/

 

[10] Respaut, Robin, Chad Terhune and Michele Conlin. “Why Detransitioners are Crucial to the Science of Gender Care,” Reuters. December 22, 2022. https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-transyouth-outcomes/

 

[11] Brownstein, Maya. “Gender-affirming surgeries rarely performed on transgender youth,” Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. July 8, 2024. https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/gender-affirming-surgeries-rarely-performed-on-transgender-youth/

 

[12] Human Rights Watch. “US: Harmful Surgery on Intersex Children, “July 25, 2017. https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/07/25/us-harmful-surgery-intersex-children

 

[13] Guttenmacher, “State Bans on Abortion Throughout Pregnancy,” June 4, 2026. https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/state-policies-abortion-bans

 

[14] Ashley Kurzweil and Katherine Gallagher Robbins. “Three Years Post-Dobbs, Abortion Bans & Criminalization Threaten More than 15 Million Women of Color.” June 2025. https://nationalpartnership.org/report/abortion-bans-and-criminalization-three-years-post-dobbs/

 

[15] “Maternal Mortality in the United States After Abortion Bans: Mothers Living in Abortion Ban States at Significantly Higher Risk of Death During Pregnancy and Childbirth.” https://thegepi.org/maternal-mortality-abortion-bans/

 

[16] Schreiber, Melody. “US moving pregnant immigrant girls to Texas to avoid providing abortions, critics say:

Ex-official calls transfer of unaccompanied girls as young as13, many pregnant due to rape, a human rights violation.” The Guardian, March 1, 2026. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/01/pregnant-immigrant-children-texas-abortion

 

[17] Jones, Rachel K. and Amy Friedrich-Karnik. “Medication Abortion Accounted for 63% of All US Abortions in 2023—An Increase from 53% in 2020,” https://www.guttmacher.org/2024/03/medication-abortion-accounted-63-all-us-abortions-2023-increase-53-2020#:~:text=New%20Guttmacher%20Institute%20research%20from,is%20highly%20safe%20and%20effective.

 

[18] Kaplan, Michael. “FDA moves ahead with safety study of abortion pill mifepristone.” June 5, 2026. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fda-launches-safety-study-for-abortion-pill-mifepristone/

 

[19] While her emphasis is on how Western imperialism and racism have combined with some feminist tendencies, discussing Islamophobia as a reactionary force doesn’t mean that one can’t also discuss the awful gender policies in places like Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan, for example. Certainly, there are feminists in the region that are anti-imperialist, anti-racist and critical of their own government for these gendered policies.

 

[20] Lewis, Sophie. 2025. Enemy Feminisms. P. 240.

 

[21] Fanon, Frantz. 1969. The Wretched of the Earth. Penguin Books, p. 165.

 

[22] “What are Shield Laws?” Center for Reproductive Rights. October 9, 2025, https://reproductiverights.org/resources/what-are-shield-laws/

 

[23] Maddow-Zimet, Isaac and Candice Gibson. “Despite Bans, Number of Abortions in the United States Increased in 2023.” Guttmacher Institute. March 2024.

[24] “The Impact of 2025 Anti-Transgender Legislation on Youth.” Williams Institute. January 2026. https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/anti-trans-legislation-youth/

 

[25] Rice, Ethan. “A Hopeful End-of-Year Message to the Trans, Nonbinary, Gender-Nonconforming, and Intersex Community,” Lamda Legal, December 12, 2025. https://lambdalegal.org/blogs/us_20251212_end-of-year-message-hope-transgender-nonbinary-gender-nonconforming-intersex-community/

 

[26] Lotz, Avery. “Transgender representation in public office has skyrocketed,” Axios, June 24, 2025. https://www.axios.com/2025/06/24/lgbtq-transgender-representation-growing-elections

[27] Marx, Karl. 2004. [1844] The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, p.  103 in Erich Fromm.

[28] Marx, “Address to the Communist League, in McLellan, David, ed. Karl Marx: Selected Writings, Oxford University Press, 2004. P. 305.

 

[29] Ibid. p. 311.

 

[30] Marx, Karl. 2022. Critique of the Gotha Program, PM Press. P. 59.

LEAVE A REPLY

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

0 Comments

FROM THE SAME AUTHOR

IMHO Journal
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.